The following was "lifted" from the Coop Conference in an item about
the history of Grex:
#3 of 15: by STeve Andre' (steve) on Fri, Dec 17, 1993 (10:41):
Actually Tim, that isn't right. Marcus and I first starting
talking about "another" conferencing system in town as early as
1987. That doesn't include other folks conversations either.
So there really was thought of something other than M-Net for
quite a few years before Grex happened.
During the founder's meetings, it did appear that M-Net really
was going to die. To state that it was kite's fault is too
simple. There were a lot of factors in there, all mixed together.
#4 of 15: by Rane Curl (rcurl) on Fri, Dec 17, 1993 (22:26):
Tell us the story, Steve.
#5 of 15: by TS Taylor (tsty) on Sun, Dec 19, 1993 (01:49):
OH, boy .... it's almost a PhD dissertation in and of itself, which some
socal "scientist" might consider ......... From the outsider's perspective,
which is all I have even having listened to several varities of POV, xD
there really is +no+ simple answer/story. Quoting STeve, "there wer a lot
of factors in there, all mixed together," and that's almost an understatement.
#6 of 15: by Valerie Mates (popcorn) on Sun, Dec 19, 1993 (11:05):
The short version is: Back when M-Net was the only conferencing system in
town it was owned first by Mike Myers, then by Dave Parks. Dave had a
tendency to expect the users to spontaneously send in money to keep the
system running, without being asked, and he used to get upset when the
bills came in and the user donations didn't. He would often decide to shut
the system down, forever, on 3 hours notice or less. One angel or another
always came through and saved the system from financial ruin, but the
angels all wore out after rescuing the system a couple of times.
Meanwhile, the threatened shutdowns left people leery of sending in $150
for a year's patronship on a system that might be shut down tomorrow.
Dave Parks is a wonderful, kind, caring person (I like him a lot as a
person) but his policies as a system owner tended to come across as
autocratic and abrupt.
A group of a dozen users met weekly for six months, planning a new system,
owned by its members and founded on slow, group decisionmaking. We ate
lots of pot luck dinners together and planned lots of idealistic ideas
about how Grex would work. We located the hardware and a space to put it
in. We incorporated as Cyberspace Communications, Inc., and we picked out
the name Grex. We hashed out plans for how the users would control the
system, placing incredible care in setting up a mechanism which users could
use to change any rules of the system.
I remember vividly the founders meeting on the night when the US first bombed
Iraq. It was hard to concentrate on issues as mundane as a computer system.
The twelve founders were: Denise Anderson (denise), Steve Andre (steve),
Misti Anslin (mta), Tom Doehne (arthur), Brian Dunkle (bad), Valerie Mates
(popcorn), Marc Unangst (mju) (our token minor), John Remmers (remmers),
Mary Remmers (chelsea) (or was she Mary Valdivia at the time?), Fred
Sleator, Mike Smerza (morel), and Marcus Watts (mdw). Glenda Andre was
present at lots of meetings, too.
We worried that users wouldn't feel a sense of ownership in the system, so
we held a big "Friends of Grex ('FOG')" meeting at Island Park shortly
before the system opened. Quite a number of M-Net users showed up. There
were a couple of issues the founders hadn't come to any decision on, so we
worked these issues out at the FOG meeting to practice group decision
making face to face. The first fairwitnesses of the Agora conference were
chosen: Katie Geddes and Larry Kestenbaum.
That was two and a half years ago. It's been about 3 years since the first
founders meetings. Grex has grown past my wildest dreams. I'd figured it
would remain no bigger than an expensive playground for the founders.
Instead, today there are hundreds of users and a thriving system.
I am pleased.
#7 of 15: by Dan Romanchik (danr) on Sun, Dec 19, 1993 (11:09):
Here's my take on the Dave Parks controversy.
M-Net, like Grex, is fairly expensive to operate. M-Net is undoubtedly
more expensive because they have more phone lines. These bills were
Parks' responsibility because he owned m-net lock, stock, and barrel.
At one point, the bills got to be too much for him, and he started
turning up the heat in getting people to donate. (Parks and his
predecessor, Mike Myers, had always accepted donaations, but prior to
this point were always pretty laid back about soliciting.) Every other
day it seemed like he would threaten to pull the plug unless users
started sending donations. He actually took the system off-line a
couple of times as I remember.
Parks got himself into a real Catch 22 with this strategy. He wanted
people to donate, and yet kept threatening to cease operation. Well,
it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that this was not the
smartest approach to easing his financial crisis. I, for one, was not
going to send him a cent until I could be guaranteed that the system
was going to be around for a while.
Parks' other problem was that he wanted to have his cake and eat it,
too. He wanted people to send him money, yet he did not want to
release any financial information about the system, nor did he want to
give people any control over the system. It was his fiefdom, and he
wanted to keep it that way, AND he wanted the users to pay for it.
These were the conditions that led to the formation of Grex and the
M-Net/Arbornet groups. The users that formed the M=Net/Arbornet group
purchased the system from Dave and moved it to the space where we plan
to move soon. That's about all I can say about M-net/Arbornet; I never
got involved with their politics.
#8 of 15: by Dan Romanchik (danr) on Sun, Dec 19, 1993 (11:11):
Valerie's response slipped in. Good thing we didn't contradict one
another. :)
#9 of 15: by Josh Grosse (jdg) on Sun, Dec 19, 1993 (13:50):
You may need a little more information on the financial arrangement between
Parks and Myers. It helps explain Dave's actions a little bit more -- at
the least, it gives a motive. Dave "rescued" M-Net from Mike by paying
what everyone (else) thought was a price well above market value for the
equipment and software. Dave justified this to himself by thinking he'd
bought a lot of goodwill and market value. This turned out not to be
the case. The goodwill lasted until the first threatened shutdown, and
the market value lasted only until the market found other avenues. As
we all know, personality conflicts exacerbated things, too.
#10 of 15: by Patricia Snyder-Rayl (pegasus) on Sun, Dec 19, 1993 (20:27):
The concept was good... a local pay BBS ... but it would seem the
execution of the concept was a little less than desirable. Well, I'm
just as glad to have Grex here, no matter the circumstances!
#11 of 15: by John H. Remmers (remmers) on Sun, Dec 19, 1993 (22:02):
It's interesting that once Grex went on-line to the public, it was not
very much longer that M-Net remained a single-owner system. I suspect
that the existence of Grex was a significant factor in Dave's decision
to sell M-Net for a price that someone was willing to pay. Ironically,
it was about two or three months after Grex started up that M-Net was
purchased by a group and re-organized as a non-profit corporation along
lines similar to Grex.